The Café Residential Team | McGrath Realty Inc
Carol Christiansen, The Café Residential Team | McGrath Realty IncPhone: (914) 261-7689
Email: cchristiansen@mcgrathrealtyinc.com
Real estate listing preview #1Real estate listing preview #2Real estate listing preview #3Real estate listing preview #4Real estate listing preview #5Real estate listing preview #6Real estate listing preview #7Real estate listing preview #8Real estate listing preview #9Real estate listing preview #10Real estate listing preview #11Real estate listing preview #12Real estate listing preview #13Real estate listing preview #14Real estate listing preview #15Real estate listing preview #16Real estate listing preview #17Real estate listing preview #18Real estate listing preview #19Real estate listing preview #20Real estate listing preview #21Real estate listing preview #22Real estate listing preview #23Real estate listing preview #24Real estate listing preview #25Real estate listing preview #26Real estate listing preview #27Real estate listing preview #28Real estate listing preview #29Real estate listing preview #30Real estate listing preview #31Real estate listing preview #32Real estate listing preview #33Real estate listing preview #34Real estate listing preview #35Real estate listing preview #36Real estate listing preview #37Real estate listing preview #38Real estate listing preview #39Real estate listing preview #40Real estate listing preview #41Real estate listing preview #42Real estate listing preview #43Real estate listing preview #44
listing
1 of 44
Single FamilyFor Sale
$1,875,000
4235 Camp Mineola Road
Mattituck, NY 11952
Listed by: William Raveis New York LLC, 631-298-0600
MLS: OneKey MLS
4Beds
2Baths
2,072Sq Ft
Est. Mortgage
$9,778/mo

Mattituck, North Fork – Bayfront Treasure in Historic Camp Mineola Exceptional Value • Private Beach • Transferable Rental Permit Jump into the North Fork lifestyle with this captivating bayfront retreat in the charming and historic Camp Mineola community of Mattituck. Featuring nearly 50 feet of private sandy shoreline and panoramic views of the Peconic Bay, this four-bedroom waterfront home offers a rare combination of tranquility, character, and investment potential—all at an outstanding value. Originally established in the early 1900s to rival the nearby Salt Lake Village, Camp Mineola has gracefully evolved from a seasonal bungalow enclave into a highly sought-after neighborhood blending timeless charm with modern convenience. Nestled within the hamlet of Mattituck in the Town of Southold, the community offers a peaceful, coastal setting just minutes from some of the North Fork’s most beloved destinations. As you arrive, the fresh salt air and soft bay breezes welcome you. A picturesque pea-stone driveway leads past a detached garage and into a picket-fenced front yard bursting with lush emerald lawn, vibrant hydrangeas, and summer blooms. The raised front porch sets the tone for what’s inside—a warm and inviting home designed to celebrate the beauty of its waterfront setting. Inside, the open-concept main level is ideal for relaxed living and seamless entertaining. The sun-filled great room flows effortlessly into a dining area and thoughtfully designed kitchen with a breakfast bar. A comfortable lounge area includes bonus refrigeration, perfect for serving the expansive south-facing terrace overlooking the bay—with private stairs leading directly into the water. This level also offers a spacious first-floor bedroom, full bath, pantry, laundry room, mechanicals, and ample closet space—ideal for hosting guests or single-level living. Upstairs, wake up to breathtaking, 180 degree water views from any of the three additional bedrooms. Enjoy brilliant sunrises and the peaceful sounds of the bay, with vistas that stretch from Robins Island to James Creek—where boat slips and shares are available through nearby Strong's Marina. Additional features include: -A fully fenced yard, perfect for pets or young children -A large detached garage/storage building -An outdoor shower for rinsing off after beach outings, paddleboarding, or morning runs Camp Mineola’s low annual dues (approx. $300/year) cover association amenities and road maintenance. Located just minutes from the vineyards, farm stands, boutique shopping on Love Lane, and acclaimed local restaurants, this home offers a relaxed yet refined lifestyle with easy access to the Hamptons and NYC. A Rare Investment Opportunity: This property includes a transferable Southold Town rental permit, allowing you to generate income through vacation rentals of a minimum of 2-week compliant stays —a unique value-add in this high-demand market. Low taxes, historic charm, and unbeatable water access make this one of the North Fork’s best waterfront buys. Whether you're searching for a full-time residence, vacation home, or income-producing property, this Mattituck gem delivers on every level. Don’t miss this rare opportunity. Call today to schedule your private showing. Buyer broker participation warmly encouraged.

Get in touch
Information courtesy of William Raveis New York LLC is subject to verification and is not guaranteed.
Community / School Information